
This week: Court Orders New Brooklyn Democratic Leadership Reorganization; Elections: A Look at the Congressional & State Legislative Results; Elections: How Mayors Are Elected; Redistricting Amendment Prospects; Attorney General VRA Preclearance; Census: Can the New Congress Reverse the Trump Decennial Census Changes?; Around the Nation (From Redistricting Network)
LITIGATION
Brooklyn Democrats Must Follow The Rules and Reorganize
The King County Democratic Party must reorganize and elect new leaders following a sequence of several court cases before the state courts. In brief, the party must hold a series of meetings following the state election law before it can move forward with new leaders following the resignation of former Chair Rodneyse Bichotte Hermelyn, who is also a member of the state assembly. Details of the most recent court decisions follow below.
Brooklyn Democratic Party: Julio Pena III v. Nydia Velázquez et al
In ongoing litigation over the Kings County Democratic Party leadership, Julio Pena III and the party reform group he’s been working with (petitioner) ask Justice Sweeny to hold former county chair Rodneyse Bichotte Hermelyn and her allies (respondents & intervenor-respondents) in civil contempt for allegedly violating a court TRO.
On November 10, Judge Sweeney issued a decision invalidating the rules-amendments passed on August 25th , confirming that the 2024 party rules remain in effect and ordering the organizational meeting to be reconvened for limited procedural purposes.
With respect to the August 25th rules, the court held that they were never independently adopted or ratified by the full county committee at its September 23rd organizational meeting because mandatory procedural requirements were not followed.
Further, the court declared the September 23rd meeting too irregular to determine specific elections because it filled newly created officer positions that only existed under the invalid rules. Thus, the court ordered the organizational meeting to be reconvened solely to consider proposed amendments and vote on any new officer positions if the amendments are validly enacted.
On November 11th, Julio Pena III and the party reform group filed a memo in support of their motion for leave to reargue and renew. While Julio Pena III agreed with invalidating the August 25th rules and upholding the 2024 rules, the motion requests the court to vacate the directive to reconvene the organizational meeting.
The party reform group makes this motion because they claim the reconvening is unrequested relief by either party, and under the state election law that a reconvened meeting cannot lawfully adopt an amendment and immediately hold officer elections for positions created by unfiled amendments during that same session. Further, the group claims the court should declare the offices created solely under the 2026 rules as void while leaving valid offices under existing 2024 rules intact.
The reform group also argues that a subsequent November 10th order in a related case Velázquez v. Lucas creates a circular trap because the prerequisites for a reconvened meeting required an active executive committee, but the executive committee is barred from organizing first. Further, they argue organizing a meeting for nearly 3,000 members is a financial impossibility and plays into attempts by former leadership to “stack” the executive committee with unelected, appointment positions.
The court has ordered Nydia Velázquez (respondents) and Nikki Lucas (intervenor-respondents) to show cause on November 17th at 10, with respect to the reform group’s motion.
Brooklyn Democratic Party: Nydia Velázquez et al. v. Nikki Lucas et al
This case covers the ongoing litigation concerning Bichotte Hermelyn and her allies’ October 4th Zoom meeting where outgoing leadership voted to install Assembly Member Nikki Lucas as the new Executive Committee Chair.
On November 10th, Judge Sweeney issued a decision declaring the October 4th meeting null and void. The court also barred the executive committee from holding a new organizational meeting until after the full county committee reconvenes pursuant to the court’s companion ruling in Pena v. Velázquez.
The court held that Nydia Velázquez (petitioner) had standing as county committee chair because the legitimacy of the executive committee itself was in question and Julio Pena III had standing as an aggrieved candidate for executive committee chair. Further, because the 2024 party rules governed, a quorum of 24 voting state committee members were required and only 13 attended the October 4th meeting. Thus, without a quorum, the attendees lacked authority to conduct business, rendering the officer elections void.
Also, the court ordered that no executive committee organizational meeting may occur until after the full county committee reconvenes to vote on any proposed changes and that any subsequent executive committee meeting must then follow either adopted rules or the 2024 party rules.
ELECTIONS
The 2026 State & Local Elections: A Review
Adapted from an Update by the Greenberg Traurig Albany office authored by Joshua Oppeneheimer and Samir NeJame
Statewide offices: With approximately 90% of the election districts counted, incumbent Gov. Kathy Hochul won a second full term by approximately 20 percentage points. Attorney General Letitia James and Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli also won reelection by similar margins.
State Senate: Democrats expanded their majority from 41 to 47 (with one race too close to call as of the date of this GT Alert), regaining the supermajority they lost in 2024.
State Assembly: Democrats retained their supermajority, expecting the conference to grow to 111 of the 150 seats.
Turnout: Early voting reached 1,965,043 votes, up about 67% from 2022.
Turnover: More than 50 incumbent legislators will not return in 2027, due to a combination of retirements and primary season losses, plus incumbents defeated on Nov. 3, 2026. These departures set up a possibility for leadership and committee changes for the 2027 session.
Congress: Democrats won 20 of New York’s 26 U.S. House seats, representing a net gain of one, and one seat where the Democrat has not yet conceded. In half of the New York House seats that the Republicans won, they did so by a margin of less than 3 percentage points. Results in some of the most hotly contested seats are summarized below.
New Yorkers voted on every statewide office, all 213 seats in the state legislature (63 in the Senate and 150 in the Assembly) and all 26 of the state’s seats in the U.S. House of Representatives. Democrats entered the election with a 41–22 majority in the state Senate, one seat short of the 42 needed for a two-thirds supermajority, and a 103–47 majority in the state Assembly, three seats above the 100 needed. Democratic control of both houses was not in serious doubt, and incumbents were heavily favored in most statewide races. The open questions were the size of the Democratic majorities, how much turnover the legislature would see, and whether there would be enough of a draw for top-of-the-ticket races to lead to a growth of the Democratic members of the congressional delegation.
The 2026 cycle also brought unusually high turnover. Before Election Day, at least 38 incumbent state legislators were already certain not to return: 31 retired or declined to seek re-election (five senators and 26 Assembly members), and seven lost primaries (two senators and five Assembly members). No incumbent Democrats lost their seats to challengers in the general election, but another five Republican Senate incumbents lost, and seven Republican assemblymembers lost. Some of the most prominent departures from retirements include Senate Deputy Majority Leader Michael Gianaris and Assembly Majority Leader Crystal Peoples-Stokes. The election determined who will fill these open seats and how the new members will affect each chamber’s political and institutional makeup.
The results of the 2026 election will reshape the legislature’s leadership and committee structure. State Senate rules limit service as party leader, committee chair and ranking member to eight consecutive years. For Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins’ tenure to continue in 2027, the conference would need to amend the body’s rules, a vote that cannot occur until the 2027 session begins. The Assembly will also see changes at the top due to retirements by Majority Leader Peoples-Stokes and former Minority Leader Will Barclay. There will be substantive changes to a number of committee chairs. These changes may help determine the legislature’s priorities, committee agendas, and points of access for advocates as the 2027 session begins.
Mayoral Election Systems in the 100 Biggest U.S. Cities
Reinvent Albany looked at how the 100 biggest cities in the United States select their mayors. It found that cities choose mayors in a totally different way than how their state’s voters choose governors, members of Congress, or presidents. Though many details differ, 90% of big cities have completely open mayoral elections in which members of any party can vote or run. Only six percent of cities have closed primaries, including New York City and Buffalo.
Highlights:
Open Elections: 89 cities hold completely open elections in which party registration does not determine who is eligible to vote or run.
Semi-Open Election: 5 cities have “semi-open primaries” in which voters not registered to a political party can vote in a closed party primary.
Closed Elections: 6 cities hold closed elections in which party registration determines whether a voter is eligible to vote or run in an election.
Deep Blue Cities with High Voter Turnout Hold Open Elections: Voter turnout is extremely high in the deeply Democratic cities that hold open elections and use Ranked-Choice Voting. Compare NYC’s 2025 general election mayoral vote of 41.6% of registered voters — the highest in 50 years — to San Francisco’s 79%, Phoenix’s 77%, and Portland, Oregon’s 66%.
New York City and Buffalo Among 6% of Cities with Closed Elections
NYC, Buffalo, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Charlotte, and Baltimore are the only six of the biggest 100 cities holding closed elections. These cities hold closed primary elections in which voters must be registered members of a political party to vote or run in a closed party primary.
NYC and Buffalo are the only two cities that allow candidates to run on more than one ballot line in the general election. Two states, New York and Connecticut, allow cities to use “disaggregated fusion,” where a candidate can appear on multiple ballot lines and have their votes from each line combined: for instance, the Democratic Party and Working Families Party lines.
NYC and Buffalo allow losing primary candidates to run in the general election. Many cities do not allow “sore losers,” like Andrew Cuomo in NYC 2025, to run in the general election. Some even prevent “sore losers” from running as write-in candidates, like Byron Brown in Buffalo 2021.
New York City and Buffalo both have a large share of unaffiliated voters who cannot vote in Democratic Party primaries. Because Democrats far outnumber Republicans in both cities, the Democratic primary winner is typically the favorite for mayor.
Working Families Party Wins Row C on Future State Ballots
In the Albany Times Union on November 16th, Dan Clark reports. that the state’s Working Families Party (WFP)will move up from Row D to Row C, bumping the state’s Conservative Party who will drop down one line. Party ranking on the ballot is based on the state Governor vote and the WFP pulled in approximately 375,000 votes compared to the 235,000 votes won by Republican challenger Bruce Blakeman on the Conservative Party line. Political parties are required to receive at least 130,000 votes of 2% of the total votes in a race for president or governor.
New York permits fusion voting and the minor party votes are added to the major party’s totals for candidates who run on more than one line when determining final outcomes.
REDISTRICTING
Will New York Have a New Congressional Map in 2028?
Since election day, New Yorkers have been refocusing on a pending state constitutional amendment to reform the state’s redistricting process and to permit a mid-decade congressional remapping before the 2028 elections. The state legislature is primed to approve an amendment for the second time in 2027 and voters may be asked to approve a congressional remapping after most recent partisan attempts to change maps in other states failed to produce the partisan gains originally projected.
Since Albany Democrats retained strong control of both legislative chambers after the 2026 elections, there is no obstacle to obtaining second passage in 2027. The amendment needs only a simple majority in each chamber before it can be placed before voters. The political argument for the amendment, however, may change from where it was six months ago. Before the election, supporters argued that Republican-redrawn maps in Texas, Florida and North Carolina could determine House control and required a New York response. After Democrats won back the U.S. House earlier this month, there is some question whether the urgency is now as strong as in the Spring.
While a New York amendment may no longer be seen as an emergency measure, advocates also do not want to necessarily abandon it because newly redrawn maps elsewhere will remain in place through future election cycles and there are no guarantees that Democrats will hold all the newly won districts in other states. Further, New York faces the loss of several congressional districts after the 2030 census, so Democrats may see the need to keep the new congressional majority strong through redistricting.
There is also the question whether another expensive and politically contentious redistricting battle is worth pursuing now that Democrats have already made significant congressional gains. While Democrats spent little to promote a redistricting reform amendment in 2021, Republicans organized and spent millions to successfully defeat the measure.
Supporters of a New York congressional remapping argue that new Republican maps remain on the books, the new Democratic House majority could again become highly competitive in 2028, and that New York should not permanently disarm while other states retain aggressive redistricting authority.
The biggest obstacle to a New York remapping is a November 2027 referendum question. The largest risk may not be Albany but the statewide electorate. The amendment would ask voters to approve changes that critics describe as repealing New York’s constitutional prohibition on partisan gerrymandering, giving the Legislature greater power over district maps, and authorizing redistricting between censuses.
These may be difficult propositions to sell to many voters. Opponents, including Republican redistricting strategist and former Congressman John Faso, have already framed the amendment proposal as dismantling reforms that voters approved in 2014. He argues that even though other GOP-held states have recently redrawn their districts, “two wrongs don’t make a right,” Faso told Spectrum News. “And I’m very much against midterm redistricting.”
Ironically, the strongest long-term argument for passage may not be 2028 at all.
If projections remain accurate, New York is expected to lose several congressional seats after the 2030 census. Meanwhile, states such as Texas, Florida, North Carolina, and Georgia may gain seats. Democratic strategists view the amendment as a way to gain seats before 2030, cushion later reapportionment losses, and establish more legislative flexibility before the next census cycle. That argument may gain strength as discussion shifts from 2028 to the post-2030 redistricting landscape.
In sum, the interesting question in 2027 may not be whether the state legislature passes the amendment again but whether New York voters are willing to repeal anti-gerrymandering provisions they themselves adopted in 2014 in exchange for giving Albany more flexibility in future congressional map wars.
CENSUS
Hey, Soon-To-Be Democratic Majority…Is It Time to Use the Congressional Review Act on the 2030 Census?
By Mike Schneider
It may be far down the list of things Democrats want to accomplish in the new Congress that gets sworn in first thing next year.
But if they wanted to, the Democratic majority could try to put a wrench in a Trump administration rule change that experts worry will badly degrade the 2030 census results.
The administration’s proposed rule change would cut out unauthorized immigrants and those in the United States without a green card from the 2030 census population numbers used to divide up congressional seats and Electoral College votes among the states.
It also would eliminate questions about race and ethnicity from the census questionnaire for the first time and prohibit questions about sexual orientation. Tax records would be used to help determine where a person should be counted, and the change would require a person to be counted where they spend the most days between Jan. 3 and April 1
Some Republicans believe the changes can give their party a leg-up when redrawing political districts.
The wrench that Democrats could throw into the system comes courtesy of the Congressional Review Act, or CRA, which gives Congress a tool to overturn rules made by federal agencies. Any joint resolution of disapproval requires the approval of both houses of Congress and enough votes to overcome a likely veto from President Donald Trump.
That wouldn’t be easy, but it’s possible.
Democrats this month won 256 of the 435 House seats, with around 10 races still to be called. They would need the backing of dozens more Republican colleagues to overcome a presidential veto.
With 55 Democratic senators expected in the upcoming Congress, and the possibility of No. 56 from Alaska, it would require the support of around a dozen Republican senators.
At least one GOP senator already has joined in opposition with the Democrats.
Republican U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska signed a letter with two dozen Democratic senators and independent Angus King, urging the Commerce Department and the Census Bureau to rescind the rule.
“The proposed rule violates the clear meaning of the Constitution, which requires that the Census Bureau count the ‘whole number of persons in each state,’” the letter said. “The proposed rule would also cause communities across the country to be counted inaccurately, jeopardizing their fair representation in Congress and access to billions of federal dollars for education, health care, and public safety services.”
The public comment period ended at the beginning of the month. Of the more than 148,500 published comments, 88% oppose the proposed rule, according to an analysis conducted for Hands Off Our Census, a consortium of nonprofits, researchers and advocacy groups.
The Census Bureau must now write a response to the comments. The proposed final rule is then sent to the White House for review during which time outside parties can request meetings with the federal officials to discuss it.
If it is finalized, the rule is published in the Federal Register and typically takes effect a month later. That’s when Congress has a chance to review the rule under the Congressional Review Act, which was enacted in 1996.
Up until last year, only 20 rules had been overturned by Congress. But they skyrocketed last year as a Republican-dominated Congress overturned a series of rules from the Biden administration.
Passing a joint resolution of disapproval next year would probably be an easier lift in the Senate than the House since several House members have been vocal supporters of eliminating noncitizens from the once-a-decade head count, said Chris Marcum, a former White House official on science and data policy who helped organize Hands Off Our Census.
But some lawmakers may be persuaded by demonstrations of how the rule change would negatively impact their districts.
“So, my read is that a CRA is likely to pass but not veto proof, if we can get it on the floor,” Marcum told me in an email.
Other routes to stopping the rule once it gets final approval is litigation and a legislative prohibition on spending any money developing the regulation. There’s also the possibility of an about-face by the next administration but that won’t be until 2029, a year before the execution of the nation’s head count, and it depends on who wins the White House.
Mike Schneider is a retired Associated Press reporter who reports on the census.
AROUND THE NATION
From The Redistrict Network (@RedistrictNet)
November 10: “I think now what we need is not an arms race on redistricting but real anti-gerrymandering laws in this country and redistricting reform,” said
@GovernorShapiro of Pennsylvania. — @RedistrictNet [from X]
November 10: Virginia Del. Marcia Price said Tuesday morning that she wants to pursue mid-decade redistricting legislation again during the upcoming legislative session. — @RedistrictNet [from X]
November 10: The Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that a 2025 law restricting the ballot initiative process is unconstitutional and void in its entirety.
SB 1027 imposed county-by-county caps on petition signatures, plus new restrictions on circulators, petition summaries and funding. — @RedistrictNet [from X]
November 12: In the 2026 midterms, Democrats gained seats on the Ohio and Texas supreme courts, and Justice Anita Earls won reelection in North Carolina.
Those gains put control of all three courts on the ballot in 2028, making them state supreme courts to watch. — @RedistrictNet [from X]
November 13: Alaskans have rejected another effort to repeal. ranked choice voting system and open primaries, Decision Desk HQ (DDHQ) projects. — @RedistrictNet [from X]
November 13: Montana’s American Indian Caucus will reach a record 14 members in the 2027 Legislature, the largest in state history.
A few of the new Caucus members include Erin Farris-Olsen in MT-SD-41, Lona Running Wolf in MT-HD-16, and Katie Fire Thunder in MT-HD-59, among others. — @RedistrictNet [from X]
November 14: The election of Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins (D) as Alaska’s governor in Nov. 2026 means he will appoint two of the state’s five redistricting board members in 2030 — @RedistrictNet [from X]
INSTITUTE RESOURCES
The New York Elections, Census and Redistricting Institute has archived many resources for the public to view on our Digital Commons Page.
Our Redistricting Resources page contains resources on the John R. Lewis Voting Rights Act. You can access the page here: https://digitalcommons.nyls.edu/redistricting_resources/
Archived Updates can be accessed here: https://digitalcommons.nyls.edu/redistricting_roundtable_updates/
Please share this weekly update with your colleagues. To be added to the mailing list, please contact Jeffrey.wice@nyls.edu
The N.Y. Elections, Census & Redistricting Institute is supported by grants from the New York Community Trust, New York Census Equity Fund, the Mellon Foundation, and the New York City Council. This report was prepared by Jeff Wice, Esha Shah, & Jason Fierman of @RedistrictNet.
October 5, 2026
New York Election Law News